College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

OPINION: Liberals can be closed minded too

By Elizabeth Johnson, Columnist

Print this article

Published: Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Updated: Wednesday, April 8, 2009

 

I hate being political. I hate the separation it causes between people of different ideologies. I hate the blind despising it causes towards those of a different political party than your own.

For four years at Whitworth I have remained apolitical for the sake of peacekeeping, my own sanity and conflict avoidance. I’ve sat amongst friends while they called members of my own ideology retarded, racist, Nazi, uneducated, uninformed, morally inferior, anti-feminist, elitist and many other less than pleasant names.

Since I am from Alaska, almost everyone I know pestered me about Sarah Palin and Ted Stevens during last year's elections. They would ask me where I'm from in Alaska, in the hopes that my answer would be Wasilla and that I would join them in the glee of bashing her. They would start a long-winded speech about how Palin loves shooting wolves from airplanes for sport, how she's ignorant because people claimed she said she could see Russia from her house and how Stevens is an ancient, corrupt politician who deserves to be hung out to dry.

After a while I just stopped responding to their questions. I stopped answering, not because I didn't have answers to their claims, but because they wouldn't ask me about Palin or Stevens for my insight or opinion. They asked me simply as a precursor to judging and bashing these people and issues.

The intolerance for any viewpoint other than their own was so impassioned that it was hard at times to be cordial while spending time with them. They were my friends, though, my closest friends. They spent hours loathing the intolerance of some fundamentalists, never stopping to think that being intolerant of those who are intolerant is still intolerance.

I am conservative. I am educated, I am not racist, I am not anti-feminist, nor am I any of the other things they claim that members of my ideology, and thus myself, are. The characterization of conservatives as mindless drones does nothing for this country except keep genuine debate from occurring between opposing views.

I do not hate members of different classes than my own, different races than my own. I do not pine for their demise. On the contrary, I desire for every American to succeed. I don’t care if you are Hispanic, Asian, female, male, rich, poor, I want you to succeed. And that is what other conservatives also desire.

I would almost say that those who desire for members of other races, classes and genders to not succeed are not only not conservative, they are not American. For this is what America was founded on, that every person in this country should be given and equal right to work hard and labor for their own success. However, in America you have the luxury of a level of free speech nearly unparalleled in the rest of the world, and that is why there are racists.

Certainly there are conservatives who are uninformed, just as there are liberals who are uninformed. We don't like it when this sect of our ideology is played out as the majority. Don’t liberals also dislike it when the most asinine of their leanings are publicized? We don’t want to be characterized by the weakest of our group. It is lazy thinking to make a blanket statement that conservatives are racist, rich, white bigots. It is simply untrue.

In all my years at Whitworth, the most closed-minded and intolerant people I’ve met were those claiming to be the exact opposite. They did not think introspectively about ideas different than their own, they discarded them as loony and stupid, not even worthy to be entertained by their far superior mindsets. It was an elitism the likes of which I have never experienced in any other group of people.

It's possible that my liberal friends won’t like me after this article. I hope they look beyond it, because I truly love them, regardless of what their political leanings are. If not, so they say, those who mind don’t matter and those who matter don’t mind.

 
Johnson is an opinions columnist and a senior majoring in journalism. Comments can be sent to elizabeth.johnson@whitworthian.com.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

7 comments

Julie Colombo
Fri Jul 31 2009 20:34
Great article Elizabeth. I sent it on to the Independent Women's Forum. Stick with journalism.
Greg
Fri May 22 2009 11:43
I think its interesting that this discussion needed to be framed as "liberals" being close-minded. It has more to do with discussing politics in public and very little to do with the given political leanings of a group. As a "liberal", I very often find myself in a group of "conservatives" that feel free to discuss the current administration, or 4 years ago, the perceived faults of the democratic candidate without regard to the one, or several in the group that might not feel the same way. I'm sorry that in this case your beliefs were in the minority, but be certain that this occurs both ways all the time depending on your chosen surroundings and the company you choose to keep.
Your name
Wed Apr 29 2009 16:36
Very well said.

I am a political conservative as well. In the time during the election I would shy away from openly getting into political discussions with people who didn't share my views because it would end in either Bush bashing or jokes about Palin. Quite frankly I just got sick of it. I was sick of not being able to have a discussion without the risk of it ending in personal jokes or attacks. I like politics. I have my opinions and feel strongly about them, but I am hesitant to share them sometimes because I know that around certain people I cannot get an objective discussion. For this reason few people realize just how strongly I believe what I believe. I am perfectly willing to talk to a liberal who does not share my views, but all I ask is that they have more to say than how dumb they think Palin is. It is especially difficult for me as well because most of these people are my friends and I know that loud arguing and name calling will not help our friendship at all so I just don't bring it up or get involved in discussions.

Sometimes it drives me a little crazy to sit back and listen, but I figure it's better than causing unnecessary conflict. But that's partly my nature. I pick my battles by deciding what will be more beneficial to the relationship overall.
It is very difficult for me not to respond back with my own jokes about Obama. I have resigned myself to just not giving my opinion that often unless seriously asked. Even then I might not.

Thanks for writing this. I'm glad someone finally had the guts to come out and talk about this because it's something that needs to be considered by everyone on both sides of the aisle.

Charles Loeffler
Mon Apr 27 2009 22:41
I often find it ironic when people who call themselves "liberal" (meaning "free") chain their minds down just for the sake of being loyal to certain ideologies. Similarly, "conservatives" can often be leaders in changing current policies, contradicting their own label. I think it's much better to take decisions and stances one at a time rather than try to figure out which opinion your ideological "team" would side with. It makes you a more informed and independent individual, like Jerod said. It also sucks whatever supposed validity there may be out of group stereotypes of liberals/conservatives (tree huggers, racists, reverse racists, hicks, etc.). Thanks for the great article!
kay
Thu Apr 9 2009 22:28
I'm a "liberal" per say, but I accept both sides of the table equally because I'm not partial to one party at all times. I don't play favorites and it does upset me we do the attacking...I usually step back from a conversation when that happens. Politics is just one big bag on poo and Sometimes I just don't step in.
Gabrielle Vaughn
Thu Apr 9 2009 20:20
As a Whitworth liberal, and as someone who habitually made/makes Palin jokes, I apologize. I myself have close conservative friends, and although there is occasional shallow sniping (from both sides), the sniping usually involves into mutually beneficial & uplifting discussions of both our beliefs. I hope after this article that maybe you & your friends may be able to have discussions of a similar nature.
Jerod Jarvis
Thu Apr 9 2009 01:45
Agreed. Attacking people or their character is the most ignorant type of debate there is. It's a logical fallacy, it accomplishes nothing, and it just makes you look uninformed. Get informed and involved in intelligent debates...don't just hop on hate bandwagons.

A well-written article, Elizabeth.







log out